The Elmira Police Department in Elmira, New York, issued the following press release on March 15, 2024:

Mary Theresa Simpson-60th Anniversary Update

On Sunday March 15th 1964, 12-year-old Elmira girl Mary Theresa Simpson was reported missing to the Elmira Police Department. Four days later on March 19th 1964, her body was discovered covered with rocks and debris on Combs Hill Rd by residents of the area.

In 2022, the Elmira Police Department was awarded funding through a grant request with Season of Justice. Season of Justice is a nonprofit dedicated to providing funding for investigative agencies and families to help solve cold cases and bring resolution to those impacted by unsolved violent crimes. The funds have been allocated for advanced DNA testing and analysis conducted by Texas based Othram Inc. This specialized testing is in relation to DNA found on Mary Theresa Simpson’s blouse by the New York State Police Forensic Investigation Center in the year 2000. Recent advances in DNA technology will allow the recovered profile from the blouse to be used for genetic genealogy and family tree research.

In 2023, the Elmira Police Department Detective Bureau partnered with the Criminal Investigation Resource Center (CIRC) at Russell Sage College. The Center is operated under the direction of Dr. Christina Lane, a criminologist and an associate professor of criminal justice at Russell Sage. The CIRC is only the second center of its kind in New York State and one of less than a dozen such centers in the nation. Thus far, the Center has provided invaluable assistance to the Department including case organization and digitizing of documents, site surveys, and in-depth review of documents, suspects, and forensics to further the investigative efforts of this case.

Despite the age of this homicide, the Elmira Police Department continues to ask anyone with information about this crime to call the Elmira Police Department at (607) 737-5626 or leave a message on the anonymous tip-line at (607) 271-HALT.

More information on the partnerships described above can be found online:
https://seasonofjustice.org/
https://unresolvedcases.sage.edu/

Coverage of the case by WENY News can also be found online.

Recent News

November 4, 2026

Five From Arthur O. Eve HEOP at Russell Sage Lead Session at Statewide Workshop

Leaders and academic counselors from Russell Sage College’s Arthur O. Eve Higher Education Opportunity Program (HEOP) shared their expertise at New York State’s Opportunity Program Fall Training Conference hosted at Hamilton College, October 15 and 16, 2026. Executive Director Jermaine Privott, Associate Director Tasha Pringle, and Academic Success Counselors Darlene Tiburcio, Deanna Cooper, and Alex […]
Read More
October 30, 2026

Russell Sage Receives Campus Prevention Network’s Seal of Prevention™ for the Seventh Consecutive Year 

Seal of Prevention Recognizes Programming That Supports Wellness and Safety Russell Sage College has received the 2026 Campus Prevention Network Seal of Prevention. Presented by Vector Solutions, the recognition honors institutions that effectively use Vector Solutions’ online courses to deliver education on sexual violence prevention, mental health, and substance misuse. “Digital education gives us a […]
Read More
October 28, 2026

Club Spotlight: Gator Productions Brings Theatre Opportunities to All at Russell Sage College

Gator Productions, one of Russell Sage College’s newest clubs, may have been founded by five Musical Theatre majors, but its leaders are intent on including students from any discipline in the fun. Founding president Emma Davis ’29 said she knew there was a community of students at Russell Sage who had chosen other academic paths, […]
Read More
See All News